The best gas fireplace burner tray depends on your fireplace dimensions, gas type, burner layout, and whether you need a basic pan or a more complete valve kit. The five options below include two-pipe pans in several sizes, a pan with a remote-operated valve package, and a wider triple-row burner. Check the product’s actual dimensions and gas requirements against your fireplace before buying; the supplied product details do not confirm that every option fits every fireplace.
| Product | Best For | Key Distinction |
|---|---|---|
| Americangaslos 22-inch two-pipe pan | Buyers seeking a larger two-pipe option | Listed as a 22-inch model for natural gas and propane |
| Americangaslos 18-inch two-pipe pan | Buyers wanting a replacement-style kit | Includes glowing ember and connection accessories |
| Americangaslogs 15-inch two-pipe pan | Buyers considering a smaller basic burner | One-burner construction; listed as 67,000 BTU |
| Americangaslos 18-inch pan with motor valve | Buyers needing a more complete control package | Includes valve, pilot, remote, and media |
| Stanbroil 22.5-inch triple burner pan | Buyers looking for a wide, triple-row layout | Steel pan with pre-installed triple burner |
Americangaslos 22-Inch Two-Pipe Burner Pan
This Americangaslos burner pan is listed as a 22-inch, two-pipe model for gas fireplaces, gas fire pits, and gas logs. Its product name identifies natural gas and propane as fuel options. That makes it a candidate for buyers comparing a larger two-pipe tray with smaller models, provided the fireplace and gas setup match the manufacturer’s specifications.
Best for: Buyers who need a two-pipe pan in the 22-inch size range and want a model described for both natural gas and propane. It was selected because it represents the larger-size option among the listed two-pipe pans.
Check before buying: The supplied listing details do not provide full pan dimensions, included accessories, or specific connection measurements. Confirm these details and the approved fuel configuration before installation. Do not assume that a stated fuel option means the product is ready to use with either gas without any required changes.
Americangaslos 18-Inch Two-Pipe Burner Pan
This 18-inch two-pipe pan is described as a replacement for a Real Fyre G45 burner set and as suitable for most ventilated gas fireplaces on the general market. The listed package includes the burner pan, 7 ounces of glowing ember, a copper connection kit, and sealing tape. The stated pan dimensions are 18 inches long, 6 inches wide, and 2.5 inches high, with 3/4-inch-long, 1/2-inch NPT male connection hubs on both ends.
Best for: Buyers seeking an 18-inch replacement-style option with several connection and ember accessories included. The listed dimensions and parts make it easier to compare against an existing setup than a listing with no package details.
Limitation: The seller’s stated compatibility is not a substitute for checking the actual appliance model, gas type, and connection requirements. Confirm the dimensions and replacement fit before ordering.
Americangaslogs 15-Inch Two-Pipe Burner Pan
This product is a 15-inch two-pipe burner pan with one-burner construction. Its feature list describes it as a replacement for a Real Fyre G45 burner set and says it is intended for most ventilated gas fireplaces. The listed pan dimensions are 18 inches long, 6 inches wide, and 2.5 inches high, with 3/4-inch-long, 1/2-inch NPT male connection hubs at both ends. The listing states a 67,000 BTU rating.
Best for: Buyers considering a simpler single-burner assembly and comparing a lower stated BTU rating with their appliance requirements. It was selected to provide an option distinct from the two-pipe package that includes ember and connection accessories.
Limitation: The product name calls it a 15-inch model, while the feature list gives an 18-inch pan length. Verify the actual measurements and intended sizing with the seller before purchase. The listed BTU figure should also be checked against the fireplace’s requirements.
Americangaslos 18-Inch Pan With Motor Valve
This vented burner package pairs an 18-inch, two-pipe pan with a motor valve. The included items are listed as a glowing ember, copper connection kit, sealing tape, gas fireplace valve, pilot, remote, volcanic rock, and vermiculite. The seller describes the set as a replacement for a Real Fyre APK-17 manual valve kit with G45 burner. Pan dimensions are listed as 18 by 6 by 2.5 inches, with 1/2-inch NPT male connection hubs.
Best for: Buyers who want a package that includes control components and decorative media, rather than a pan alone. It stands apart from the other two-pipe listings because the feature list includes a motor valve, pilot, and remote.
Limitation: Confirm that the valve and control arrangement match the fireplace and gas system. The replacement description is the seller’s claim; check the exact appliance model and installation requirements before treating it as a compatible replacement.
Stanbroil 22.5-Inch Triple Burner Pan
The Stanbroil burner pan measures 22.5 inches long, 14 inches wide, and 1.85 inches high. It has a triple-row burner construction, and the burner is described as factory-installed. The listing says plumbing is hidden below the tray and identifies a 1/2-inch male gas inlet with 3/4-inch-long, 1/2-inch male connection hubs at both ends. Natural gas is listed as the fuel; propane use requires an air mixer.
Best for: Buyers comparing a wide tray with a triple-row burner layout and a pre-installed burner. It is the most clearly wide-format option among these products, with a stated width of 14 inches.
Limitation: The listing identifies natural gas and says propane requires an air mixer. Do not assume propane use is supported without that component and confirmation that the overall setup is appropriate for the appliance.
Buying Guide: How to Choose a Gas Fireplace Burner Tray
A burner tray supports the burner assembly and may include connection hardware, media, or controls depending on the package. The right choice is not determined by nominal length alone. Compare the pan’s exact measurements, burner layout, gas type, connection details, and included components with your fireplace specifications. If the product information is incomplete or inconsistent, confirm the details with the seller or a qualified gas appliance professional before ordering.
What size burner tray fits your fireplace?
Measure the available firebox area and compare it with the tray’s actual length, width, and height. Also consider the space needed for gas connections and any required clearances. A product’s name may use a nominal size that differs from the pan’s listed measurement. For example, the 15-inch model above has an 18-inch pan length in its feature details, so buyers should resolve that discrepancy before purchase.
Do not choose a tray solely because its length appears close to the opening width. The fireplace manufacturer’s instructions may specify compatible burner dimensions, placement, and clearance. If you are replacing an existing burner, record its model and measurements, then compare those details with the proposed replacement.
Do you need a single, two-pipe, or triple-row burner?
These descriptions refer to different burner arrangements, not a guarantee of stronger performance or better fit. The Americangaslogs 15-inch listing describes one-burner construction, while the Americangaslos options are identified as two-pipe models. Stanbroil describes a triple-row burner. Match the layout to the fireplace design and appliance requirements instead of selecting by the number of pipes or rows alone.
A wider tray can occupy more firebox space. Compare the Stanbroil’s listed 14-inch width with the available area in your fireplace. The two-pipe Americangaslos listings provide a narrower stated width of 6 inches, but their installation suitability still depends on the appliance and manufacturer’s guidance.
Which gas type does the tray support?
Check whether the listing specifies natural gas, propane, or both, and verify the exact configuration needed. The 22-inch Americangaslos product name refers to natural gas and propane. The Stanbroil listing identifies natural gas and says an air mixer is required for propane. Do not infer that a burner can switch between fuels without the correct parts or setup.
Gas appliances and burner assemblies must be installed and configured according to their instructions and applicable local requirements. If the fuel type, pressure, or conversion needs are unclear, consult a qualified professional rather than adapting connections by guesswork.
What connection measurements should you check?
Compare the connection type and size with the gas line and fireplace components. Several Americangaslos listings specify 1/2-inch NPT male hubs and describe their length, while the Stanbroil listing gives a 1/2-inch male gas inlet and connection hubs. Thread type, orientation, and included fittings can matter as much as nominal size.
Ask whether adapters or other parts are needed and whether they are included. Do not assume that a copper connection kit or sealing tape covers every installation requirement. Use only components approved for the appliance and gas system.
Is a basic pan or a complete kit better?
A basic burner pan may suit a replacement project where the existing controls and connections are already appropriate and reusable. A package with ember, connection hardware, or sealing tape can provide more of the listed parts together. The motor-valve option goes further by listing a valve, pilot, remote, volcanic rock, and vermiculite.
Compare the included-items list with what your project actually needs. A larger package is not automatically a better fit: the valve and pilot must be suitable for the appliance, and the decorative materials must be used as directed. Verify omissions before ordering so you can plan for any required components.
How should you compare claimed replacement compatibility?
Some product listings describe compatibility with Real Fyre G45 equipment or an APK-17 manual valve kit. Treat these as seller-provided claims, not universal fit guarantees. Confirm the precise model, dimensions, fuel, valve arrangement, and connection specifications against your existing equipment and the fireplace manufacturer’s documentation.
Replacement fit can depend on more than tray length. It may involve the burner configuration, ignition or pilot system, gas controls, and firebox design. When any of these details do not match, ask the manufacturer or a qualified installer to confirm suitability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can any gas fireplace burner tray fit any fireplace?
No. Tray dimensions, burner layout, gas type, connections, and appliance requirements vary. Check the fireplace documentation and exact product measurements before buying.
Can I use a natural gas burner with propane?
Not automatically. The product must support the intended fuel and have the required components and configuration. The Stanbroil listing specifically says an air mixer is required for propane use.
What does a two-pipe burner pan mean?
It identifies the burner arrangement described by the product listing. It does not establish compatibility with a particular fireplace. Compare the assembly with the appliance specifications.
Does an included remote mean the burner is universally compatible?
No. A remote is one component of a control system. Confirm that the listed valve, pilot, remote, and burner arrangement match the fireplace and installation requirements.
Should I choose a tray by its listed BTU rating?
Use the BTU information as one comparison point, not the only selection rule. The burner must meet the fireplace’s stated requirements, and the listed rating should be verified against the appliance documentation.
Who should install a gas fireplace burner tray?
Follow the product and fireplace instructions, along with applicable local requirements. If you are unsure about gas connections, fuel configuration, controls, or fit, use a qualified gas appliance professional.